|
Warner Bros |
As it so happened, the first Hobbit, An Unexpected Journey, came out before I decided to start writing reviews on my blog again. Thus, I missed my chance to lend my two cents in the form of a longer review, but since The Desolation of Smaug is the sequel to the said movie, I thought it would be best to give a very brief review of the first so as to set the stage for some comparison between the two films. For after all, a sequel is only as good in how it continues, expands, and enriches what the first began.
Over all, I thought the first film was quite charming, exciting, and endearing to those of us who have grown up reading The Hobbit or for those who have not. The visuals (especially in IMAX 3D and with the 48 ffps) were astounding and the lands, details, etc, were as rich as ever. It was fun to see bits and pieces of memorable moments from the books sprinkled throughout (for instance, the dwarves singing the wonderfully composed misty mountains song at Bag End, and Bilbo and Gollum's "riddle in the dark"), and even those that were ridiculously exaggerated but fun all the same (the stone giants come to mind). Martin Freeman as Bilbo and Richard Armitage as Thorin were very well cast, especially Freeman. Many fans seemed to have a problem with all the extra bits added to the story-line (Radagast, the giant, pale Orc with bad makeup, etc), and while it does make the movie feel a bit bogged down and distracted from the main point of the dragon, I for one don't mind them adding the extra content. Of course, they're doing so in order to stretch the book into 3 movies so they can make more money, but still, a movie is vastly different than a book and requires a lot more, obvious plot devices, problems, and development that is just common sense when you're reading. Because, after all, a book is made up of words, not images, sounds, music, dialogue, etc. My idea is that as long as the main point and plot points are communicated and enacted, I don't mind much what is added to or taken out of a movie adaptation of a book.